- Lead counsel in Midland County, TX, lease termination jury trial representing a Fort Worth-based oil and gas company against a Fortune 500 drilling company. Secured a unanimous finding that the lease terminated for failure to produce in profitable quantities and also terminated based on a total cessation of production without timely qualifying operations.
- Lead counsel in the retrial of a seminal Texas oil and gas case. In the original trial – when a different firm represented BP – the jury unanimously found that its lease terminated for failure to turn a profit. The Texas Supreme Court remanded for a new trial. As lead counsel in the retrial, Rob secured a unanimous jury verdict in BP’s favor with a finding that the lease produced in paying quantities. BP America v. Laddex, 513 S.W.3d 476 (Tex.).
- Lead appellant counsel securing a favorable reversal in a dispute over ownership over royalty interest. The Texas appeals court applied the historical 1/8 and estate misconceptions when interpreting a 1951 deed stating the client owned all a disputed interest. This reversed the trial court’s decision that the client did not own any fraction of the disputed interest. WTX Fund v. Holt, et al., No. 08-17-00104-CV (Tex. App. – El Paso).
- Lead counsel for a Dallas-based water company that prevailed with a unanimous jury verdict in a saltwater lease termination dispute in Martin County, TX.
- Lead counsel for a Midland-based operator that defeated a lease termination challenge on an almost 5,000-acre lease in Reeves County, TX, by filing suit and securing ratifications from the defendants without payment of any settlement.
- Obtained summary judgment for the primary defendant, a Fort Worth–based oil and gas company, in a lease termination dispute involving 4,000 gross mineral acres in the heart of the Delaware Basin.
- Obtained summary judgment as lead counsel for the defendant oil company facing a damages claim for over $50 million on an oil and gas lease in Loving County, TX.
- Secured summary judgment as lead counsel for the plaintiff in an ownership dispute over a lease in Scurry County, TX.
- Co-lead counsel at trial over claims for the termination of a multimillion-dollar oil and gas lease, resulting in a jury finding that the lease in question produced in paying quantities. Later obtained a full take-nothing judgment when the Texas Supreme Court held that the only material question asked of the jury was the one answered in favor of the client. BP America v. Red Deer Resources, 526 S.W.3d 389 (Tex.).
- Represented a Dallas-based oil company in resolving in a high-value lease dispute in Reeves County, TX.
- Obtained a favorable settlement for an Oklahoma-based operator in a lawsuit alleging the multimillion-dollar lease termination was due to an improper invocation of the shut-in royalty clause.
- Obtained a dismissal without payment for a Colorado-based operator and a supermajor in a lawsuit alleging lease termination and breaches of the implied covenant to reasonably develop the lease.
- Represented the CEO of an oil company in a $3.5 million lawsuit and secured a dismissal without payment.
- Lead counsel for a Fort Worth–based oil company in a dispute over the ownership of multiple square miles of valuable mineral acreage in the heart of the Midland Basin that ended in a favorable settlement.
- Represented a Texas-based operator in a dispute with a contractor over a failed fracking attempt, resulting in a favorable settlement.
- Counseled a Texas-based operator through an acquisition of a leasehold in the Permian Basin with a potential title dispute, resulting in a substantially lower than market value price, resolution of all rival claims without litigation, and the sale of the property one year later for a $40 million profit.
- Represented the prevailing party, Unit Petroleum, in an appeal in one of only two Texas cases to define the rights, limitations, and meaning of a wellbore-only lease. Unit Petroleum v. David Pond Well Service, 439 S.W.3d 389 (Tex. App. – Amarillo).
- Won a defense verdict following a two-week trial in a lease termination dispute in Moore County, TX, representing the largest working interest owner in an oil and gas lease.
Partner,
- Phone: 214.922.3550
- Email: rob.vartabedian@alston.com
An experienced trial lawyer, plaintiffs and defendants call on Rob for complex oil and gas litigation. Rob brings a strategic approach and industry knowledge to his clients’ high-stakes disputes.