Patent Case Summaries October 28, 2026

Patent Case Summaries | Week Ending October 23, 2026

Our Patent Case Summaries provide a weekly summary of the precedential patent-related opinions issued by the Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit and the opinions designated precedential or informative by the Patent Trial and Appeal Board.

Google LLC v. Valtrus Innovations Ltd.

No. 2024-1945 (Fed. Cir. (PTAB) Oct. 19, 2026). Opinion by Cunningham, joined by Hughes and Burroughs (sitting by designation).

Valtrus owns a patent directed to methods and computer-readable memory for merging search-result lists generated by multiple search engines. Google petitioned for IPR, arguing that the claims would have been obvious over combinations based primarily on the “Bushee” reference.

Bushee was filed about five weeks before the application that issued as Valtrus’s patent. Valtrus argued that the inventors conceived of the invention before Bushee’s filing date, so Bushee does not qualify as prior art under pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. § 102(e).

The Patent Trial and Appeal Board agreed that Bushee was not prior art. The Board found that several documents supported an earlier conception date, including a co-inventor’s declaration, certain “Disclosure Documents” describing the invention, and Microsoft Word metadata for those documents. The Board therefore concluded that Google had failed to show that any claim was unpatentable. Google appealed.

The Federal Circuit affirmed. Google first argued that the Board relied on “legally insufficient” evidence to corroborate the co-inventor’s conception testimony. According to Google, the Disclosure Documents and their metadata could not provide independent corroboration “because they are both entirely under [the co-inventor’s] control” and therefore insufficiently independent of his testimony.

The court disagreed. It observed that the co-inventor did not author the metadata and that the metadata therefore “independently corroborates [his] testimony.” Substantial evidence thus supported the Board’s finding that the Disclosure Documents and metadata corroborated the co-inventor’s testimony.

Google next argued that substantial evidence did not support the Board’s finding that the inventors exercised diligence in reducing the invention to practice. Google disputed the inventors’ diligence during a three-week period that included about 11 business days.

The court rejected this argument as well, holding that substantial evidence supported the Board’s finding of reasonably continuous diligence throughout the disputed period. The purpose of the diligence inquiry, the court explained, “is to assure that, in light of the evidence as a whole, the invention was not abandoned or unreasonably delayed.” Here, Valtrus “accounted for the entire period during which diligence is required, including the disputed period, using timestamp evidence of the inventors and a law firm office collaborating in the United States to complete, execute, and file the application” that issued as the patent.

Media Contact
Alex Wolfe
Communications Director