In Appeals of J. Burch, J. Carden and K. Carden, currently designated “pending precedential,” the California Office of Tax Appeals (OTA) rejected the Franchise Tax Board's (FTB) position (articulated earlier in FTB Legal Ruling 2022-02) that Internal Revenue Code Section 751(a) changes the nature of a taxpayer’s sale of a partnership interest, in part, into a deemed sale of the partnership’s underlying inventory or unrealized receivables, with the income thereon sourced to the location of the business operations. Rather, the OTA concluded that Section 751(a) is simply about the character of income and does not change the fact that a partnership interest is sold.
Therefore, the OTA concluded that for California nonresident sourcing purposes, the income of a nonresident taxpayer that sold a partnership interest must be sourced as such under the rules for income from intangible personal property set forth in California Revenue and Taxation Code Section 17952. Under those rules generally, any resulting Section 751(a) gains from the disposition of a California nonresident’s partnership interests are not treated as California-source income unless the partnership interest has otherwise acquired a California business situs.
The OTA adopted the D.C. Circuit's analysis in its 2024 ruling in Rawat v. Commissioner, finding it “highly persuasive.” In Rawat, the IRS made a substantively similar argument as the FTB that Section 751(a) causes a portion of a foreign partner’s gain from the sale of an interest in a partnership to give rise to a deemed sale of the underlying U.S. inventory, generating U.S.-source income. The D.C. Circuit rejected the IRS’s position, concluding that Section 751(a) only recharacterizes the character of partnership interest gain and does not engineer a deemed sale of the underlying partnership assets.
California nonresidents that have previously reported or expect to report gain attributable to Section 751(a) on a sale of a partnership interest may wish to evaluate their reporting positions and whether the decision supports a change in reporting or filing of refund claims for open years.
We will continue to monitor the opinion’s precedential status and any other developments.
If you have any questions, or would like additional information, please contact one of the attorneys on our Federal & International Tax team or one of the attorneys on our State & Local Tax team.
You can subscribe to future advisories and other Alston & Bird publications by completing our publications subscription form.




